Design Patent Strategy After LKQ: Navigating Prosecution, Invalidity and Enforcement

Published by Linda Raj on

Design patent prosecution, prior-art search and enforcement after LKQ.

Design patents are attracting increased attention in the United States, driven by their commercial importance, growing litigation activity, the potential for significant damages under Section 289 of the U.S. Patent Act, and developments in design patent validity following the Federal Circuit’s Landmark en banc decision in LKQ Corp. v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC (May 21, 2024).

The potential availability of an infringer’s total profit under Section 289 makes design patents commercially significant enforcement tools. At the same time, the LKQ decision, which replaced the rigid Rosen-Durling test with a more flexible obviousness framework based on the Graham factors, has changed how design patent validity challenges are evaluated.

These developments raise important considerations for patent practitioners, particularly in relation to design patent prosecution, prior-art assessments, infringement analysis and invalidity challenges.

In this blog, we will walk you through how the evolving design patent landscape is influencing prosecution and litigation strategies, and why comprehensive visual prior-art searches and design analysis are becoming increasingly important.

1. Design Patent Prosecution After LKQ

The changes introduced by LKQ make the quality of design patent prosecution particularly important. Although the decision primarily concerns obviousness, it reinforces the need for applicants to consider the prior-art landscape when developing a design patent application.

Unlike utility patent applications, design patent claims are primarily defined by the drawings. The visual disclosure therefore plays a central role in defining the scope of protection.

Applicants and patent practitioners should pay particular attention to:

  • Drawing accuracy and consistency: The views must consistently disclose the claimed ornamental design, including its contours, proportions and surface features.
  • Solid and broken lines: The appropriate use of solid and broken lines is important in defining the claimed and unclaimed portions of the design.
  • Claim scope: The decision to claim the design of an entire product or only a distinctive portion of it can influence both the breadth of protection and the relevant prior-art landscape.
  • Prior-art assessment: Relevant existing designs should be identified early to evaluate potential novelty and obviousness concerns

Following LKQ, prior-art analysis should be an integral part of prosecution strategy rather than a step reserved for litigation. A carefully prepared drawing set, deliberate claim-scope decisions and an assessment of relevant prior designs help applicants develop a more defensible design patent application.

2. Prior-Art Searches and Invalidity Challenges After LKQ

One of the most significant practical consequences of LKQ concerns how prior-art searches are conducted and how references are evaluated in obviousness challenges.

Under the earlier Rosen-Durling framework, a challenger first needed to identify a primary reference that was “basically the same” as the claimed design. If no such reference could be identified, the obviousness inquiry could effectively come to an end.

Following the LKQ decision, this rigid threshold has been eliminated. Design patent obviousness is now evaluated using the Graham factors, including the scope and content of the prior art, differences between the prior art and the claimed design, the level of ordinary skill in the relevant design field, and any relevant secondary considerations.

Importantly, LKQ did not eliminate the need for a primary reference altogether. Rather, it rejected the rigid requirement that the primary reference must be “basically the same” as the claimed design. The primary reference must still be an existing design, and the obviousness analysis must consider whether the reference qualifies as analogous art.

The analysis also requires determining of whether an ordinary designer would have been motivated to modify a primary reference to create the overall visual appearance of the claimed design.

This change makes comprehensive prior-art searches particularly important.

A. Expanding the prior-art search landscape

A design patent search should not be limited to design patent databases. Relevant visual disclosures may also be found in:

  • S. and international design patent publications.
  • Utility patent drawings containing relevant design disclosures.
  • Product catalogues and technical brochures.
  • Manufacturer websites and archived product pages.
  • Online marketplaces and product listings.
  • Industry publications and trade journals.
  • Exhibition materials and product launch announcements
  • Publicly accessible photographs, videos, news reports and other online disclosures

However, identifying a visually similar reference does not automatically establish that it qualifies as prior art. The search should consider whether the disclosure was publicly accessible before the relevant effective filing date and whether it satisfies the applicable legal requirements for prior-art status.

Additionally, the reference must be evaluated to determine whether it constitutes analogous art, rather than merely sharing an isolated visual feature with the claimed design.

B. Visual similarity and overall appearance

Design patent analysis is fundamentally visual. A search professional must evaluate the overall visual appearance of a design rather than rely solely on product descriptions, classifications or isolated design features.

For example, when assessing a vehicle front fender design, relevant considerations may include its overall contour, curvature, proportions, transitions and surface configuration.

A reference may share individual features with the claimed design without necessarily creating a similar overall visual impression. Conversely, multiple references may be relevant when considered together, provided there is an appropriate evidentiary basis for combining them.

C. Motivation to combine and the risk of hindsight

A central consideration under LKQ is whether an ordinary designer would have been motivated to modify a primary reference using features from another reference to create the claimed overall visual appearance.

The motivation does not necessarily have to be expressly stated in the prior-art documents. It may arise from the knowledge and creativity of an ordinary designer, market demands, industry practices or commonly used ornamental features.

However, the proposed combination must be supported by evidence. A challenger cannot simply select individual features from unrelated references and reconstruct the claimed design with the benefit of hindsight.

The analysis should establish why an ordinary designer in the relevant field would have considered the proposed modification, taking into account the nature of the designs, their intended uses and the available evidence.

The greater the visual differences between the references, the more important it becomes to explain and substantiate why an ordinary designer would have made the proposed modifications.

D. Visual comparison evidence

Visual comparison charts are particularly useful in post-LKQ invalidity analysis. A structured comparison should identify:

  • The claimed design and the closest relevant prior-art references.
  • The specific visual similarities and differences.
  • The proposed modifications to the primary reference.
  • The evidence supporting the motivation to make those modifications.
  • The resulting overall visual impression.

The objective is not merely to identify similar-looking products, but to establish an evidence-supported explanation of why the claimed design would or would not have been obvious to an ordinary designer.

    3. Design Patent Litigation: Infringement Analysis and Enforcement

    While LKQ has changed the obviousness analysis, it has not altered the legal framework governing design patent infringement.

    Infringement continues to be evaluated under the ordinary-observer test established by the Federal Circuit’s En Banc decision in Egyptian Goddess, Inc. v. Swisa, Inc., 543 F.3d 665 (Fed. Cir. 2008).

    Under this test, infringement may be established where, in the eye of an ordinary observer familiar with the prior art, the accused design and the patented design are substantially the same, such that the observer would be deceived into purchasing one believing it to be the other.

    The comparison should focus on the overall visual impression rather than examining individual ornamental features in isolation.

    A. The role of prior art in infringement proceedings

    Prior art also plays an important role in design patent infringement analysis. Where the patented design is similar to existing designs, the comparison may require closer attention to the features that distinguish the patented design from the prior art.

    The prior-art context can therefore influence how the claimed design is understood and how the accused product is evaluated. This is particularly relevant in industries where competing products share conventional shapes, configurations or design elements.

    B. Building an effective infringement case

    An infringement assessment should involve more than identifying visual similarities between a patented design and an accused product. It should include:

    • Reviewing the complete design patent drawing set.
    • Identifying the claimed ornamental features.
    • Comparing the accused product from corresponding views.
    • Evaluating the overall visual impression in light of relevant prior art.
    • Assessing whether the accused product applies the patented design or a colorable imitation.
    • Identifying the relevant article of manufacture and potential damages exposure.

    High-quality product images, side-by-side visual comparisons, physical product samples and expert analysis can help support the infringement assessment.

    For patent owners, the ability to demonstrate the overall visual similarity between the patented design and the accused product, while accounting for the prior-art context, remains central to an effective enforcement strategy.

    4. Design Patent Damages: Why Section 289 Matters

    One of the distinctive features of U.S. design patent law is the damages remedy under Section 289 of the Patent Act.

    Section 289 provides that a person who, without a licence, applies a patented design or a colorable imitation to an article of manufacture for sale, or sells an article of manufacture to which the design has been applied, is liable to the patent owner to the extent of the infringer’s total profit, subject to the statutory minimum.

    Unlike conventional patent damages under Section 284, which may include lost profits or a reasonable royalty, Section 289 provides a specific remedy based on the infringer’s total profit from the relevant article of manufacture.

    The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Samsung Electronics Co. v. Apple Inc., 580 U.S. 53 (2016), clarified an important aspect of this provision. The Court held that, for a multicomponent product, the relevant “article of manufacture” for calculating design patent damages need not always be the entire end product; it may also be a component of that product.

    The Court outlined a two-step approach: first, identify the article of manufacture to which the infringed design has been applied; and second, calculate the infringer’s total profit from that article of manufacture.

    This distinction is particularly relevant to products such as smartphones, vehicles and household appliances, where a patented design may relate to only one component of a larger product.

    Consequently, Section 289 can create significant financial exposure in design patent litigation. However, recovery of the total profit from an entire end product should not be assumed in every case; the relevant article of manufacture must be identified under the applicable legal framework.

    It is also important to distinguish the remedies available under Sections 284 and 289. Although both provisions may be relevant in a design patent infringement case, they do not permit duplicative recovery for the same infringement.

    5. Practical Implications for Patent Practitioners

    The developments following LKQ, together with the growing significance of design patent litigation and Section 289 damages, require patent practitioners to take a more integrated approach to design patent prosecution and enforcement.

    For applicants and patent owners

    • Prepare accurate and consistent design patent drawings that clearly define the claimed ornamental features.
    • Assess relevant prior art before filing and consider its potential impact on claim scope and validity.
    • Maintain evidence of design development, commercial success, industry recognition and copying, where relevant.
    • Review existing design patent portfolios to identify commercially important designs and potential enforcement opportunities.
    • Prepare visual comparison materials to support infringement assessments.
    • Evaluate potential damages exposure and the relevant article of manufacture under Section 289.

    Evidence of commercial success, industry praise and copying may also be relevant as secondary considerations in an obviousness analysis, provided that a sufficient connection between the evidence and the claimed ornamental design is established.

    For accused infringers and patent challengers

    • Expand prior-art searches beyond designs that appear nearly identical to the claimed design.
    • Identify relevant analogous art from patent and non-patent sources.
    • Analyse the differences between the claimed design and the identified references.
    • Establish an evidence-supported motivation to combine references.
    • Evaluate whether the claimed design would have been obvious without relying on hindsight.
    • Assess infringement under the ordinary-observer test, considering the relevant prior-art context.
    • Evaluate potential Section 289 damages exposure.

    The post-LKQ framework provides challengers with greater flexibility in developing obviousness arguments, but it also requires a disciplined analysis supported by relevant visual and documentary evidence.

    6. Role of specialised design patent searches

    The effectiveness of both prosecution and litigation strategies depends significantly on the quality of the underlying prior-art search.

    Design searches require more than conventional keyword-based searching. Relevant references may use different product terminology or appear in non-patent sources. Therefore, visual search techniques and image-based retrieval can be particularly valuable.

    Specialised search and analysis may involve:

    • Searching U.S. and international design patent databases.
    • Identifying relevant non-patent literature and publicly available product disclosures.
    • Conducting image-based and visual similarity searches.
    • Reviewing design classifications and related product categories.
    • Preparing side-by-side visual comparison charts.
    • Analysing the overall visual appearance of the claimed and cited designs.
    • Supporting patentability, invalidity and infringement assessments.

    The objective is to identify relevant visual disclosures and provide a structured assessment of how they may affect the validity and enforceability of a design patent.

    Design Patents as Strategic IP Assets

    To conclude, design patents are attracting increased attention as strategic IP assets, supported by their commercial enforcement potential, growing litigation activity, the potential damages remedy under Section 289 and significant changes in the assessment of design patent obviousness following LKQ v. GM.

    For applicants, the decision reinforces the importance of accurate drawings, deliberate claim-scope decisions and early prior-art assessments. For patent owners, it highlights the need for strong prosecution records, effective infringement analysis and evidence-based enforcement strategies. For challengers, it creates a greater need for comprehensive prior-art searches, analogous-art analysis and well-supported obviousness arguments.

    Ultimately, the strength of a design patent depends not only on obtaining a grant, but also on its ability to withstand validity challenges and provide meaningful protection against competing designs.

    As design patent prosecution and litigation continue to evolve, comprehensive visual prior-art searches, design comparison and specialised patent analysis will remain important in helping businesses and patent practitioners protect and enforce commercially valuable designs.

     


    Linda Raj

    Linda, Lead Patent Scientist at DexPatent, is dedicated to aiding IP Counsel and Patent attorneys in Patent research and management. Her interests span from reading books to writing on subjects related to innovation, work, and life.

    0 Comments

    Leave a Reply

    Avatar placeholder

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Explore Featured Articles

    Apple receives a patent for a smart ring capable of health monitoring and device control

    Apple receives a patent for a smart ring capable of health monitoring and device control

    Google’s future AR Glasses will capture in-air gestures in sync with accessories

    Google’s future AR Glasses will capture in-air gestures in sync with accessories

    Can You Patent Your University Project?

    Can You Patent Your University Project?

    Centered Image

    Patent Newz Box is a collection of carefully handpicked Patent & IP news items delivered fortnightly, straight to your inbox, It helps you to stay on top of Global Patent News.

    fast
    Consistent

    DexPatent consistently delivers high-quality reports.

    fast
    Reliable

    DexPatent is a trusted partner for many MNCs and law firms.

    fast
    Fast

    DexPatent’s quick response shows we respect your time.

    Get in touch with us

    Get a Quote

    Please check your answer
    Schedule a Call

    Schedule a Call