Should I file a utility patent or a design patent?
Protecting your intellectual property is crucial, and both utility and design patents offer distinct avenues. However, choosing the right path can be confusing. Fear not, this guide demystifies the process and helps you pick the ideal shield for your creation.
A utility patent protects the functional aspects of an article, while a design patent protects only the ornamental appearance of an article.
To understand the key differences, imagine you invent a unique bottle opener.
Utility Patent: Focuses on functionality. Does your opener employ a novel mechanism that efficiently pops caps? If yes, a utility patent safeguards that mechanism, preventing others from copying its innovative functionality.
Design Patent: Focuses on visual appearance. Does your opener boast an eye-catching, sculpted handle? If so, a design patent shields that unique aesthetic, ensuring competitors cannot mimic its look and feel.
Few famous examples of utility patents include patents granted for Telephone (US Patent No. 174,465), Light Bulb (US Patent No. 224,308), Airplane (US Patent No. 1,161,595) and Transistor (US Patent No. 2,525,345).
Few famous examples of design patents include patents granted for Coca-Cola Bottle (1915), Monopoly Game Board (1935), Hershey's Kiss Wrapper (1907), Rubik's Cube and Apple Macintosh Trash Can Icon.
Here are the key differences between Utility and Design patents:
|
Utility Patent
|
Design Patent
|
|
Protects the functional aspects of an invention.
|
Protects the appearance (i.e. ornamental design) aspects of an invention |
| Harder and takes significantly longer to obtain |
Comparatively easier and quick to obtain |
| More costly to obtain |
Less costly to obtain |
| Valid for twenty years from the date of the application filing. |
Valid for fifteen years from the date of grant |
| Periodic maintenance fees to prevent them from expiration |
Do not require payment of maintenance fees. |
To determine which one suits you best, focus on the functionality first. Prioritize utility patents if (a) Your invention's unique value lies in how it works. (b) The core innovation resides in its mechanism, process, or function. (c) Functionality is the primary selling point, even if the design is simple.
Consider design patents if: (a) Your invention's distinctive appearance sets it apart. (b) The visual design is integral to its functionality or brand identity. (c)You want to prevent competitors from copying the look and feel, even if they use different mechanisms.
You can file for both utility and design patent if your invention possesses unique functionality and a distinct appearance.
Utility patents guard the functional aspects of your invention whereas design patents shield the unique visual appearance. To determine which one suits you, analyze what makes your invention special: functionality, aesthetics, or both.